Small Tract Rights-of-Way: McCarrey v. Kaylor

A “Small Tract” parcel authorized under the 1938 Small Tract Act is one of several federal land disposals by which a citizen may obtain a patent to public lands. By federal regulation, a Small Tracts patent may include a specific width right-of-way for roadway and utilities purposes. The 2013 Alaska Supreme Court case McCarrey v. Kaylor changed the common view of what a Small Tract right-of-way is and how to determine its validity.  The presentation provided below was made at the 2019 Alaska Surveying & Mapping Conference. 

Due to their size of less than 5-acres, a Small Tract parcel has been referred to as a "jack-rabbit homestead".  The BLM online database suggests that more than 5,500 Small Tract patents were issued  between 1950 and 1984.  To provide access to and through the Small Tract parcels, each patent typically included  a statement similar to the following: "This patent is subject to a right-of-way not exceeding 33 feet in width, for roadway and public utilities purposes, to be located along the west and south boundaries of said land."  In later patents, the ROW width was increased to 50-feet.  The question discussed in this report is whether the apparent patent reservation actually exists.

Date Documents